Difference between revisions of "Garnishment (No. 251)"

From Clicklaw Wikibooks
 
(14 intermediate revisions by 4 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{Dial-A-Law Blurb}}
+
{{REVIEWEDPLS | reviewer = [https://www.morellichertkow.com/rachel-r-lammers.htm Rachel Lammers], Morelli Chertkow LLP|date= July 2018}} {{Dial-A-Law TOC|expanded = money}}
 +
When a debtor doesn’t pay a debt, a creditor may try to access money owed to the debtor by someone else. The creditor can do this through a process called '''garnishment'''.
  
{{Dial-A-Law TOC|expanded = credit}}
+
==Understand your legal rights==
This script discusses a legal proceeding called “garnishment,” used to collect money on a judgment or debt.
 
  
==What is garnishment?==
+
===Garnishment is a way to collect a debt===
Garnishment is a drastic measure for collecting a debt, governed by Part 1 of The ''Court Order Enforcement Act''. It allows a creditor to “attach” (intercept and take) the wages and debts owed to a debtor by others, before that property is paid to the debtor.
+
Under the [http://canlii.ca/t/84h5 law in BC], if a debtor doesn’t pay a debt, a creditor can tap into money the debtor is owed by someone else (that is, a third party).  
  
For example, say you (as the debtor) owe someone money and that person (the creditor) is suing you. You’re expected to pay the creditor back. Now, if someone else is indebted to you, the creditor can intercept the money owing to you by requiring the money be paid into court, instead of to you.
+
The creditor must go to court to do this. They can ask the court to “attach” (or “'''garnish'''”) money owed to the debtor and redirect it to the creditor.  
  
Often the money garnished or intercepted is money in the debtor’s bank account (money “owed” by the bank to the debtor) or wages owed to the debtor by an employer. In either case, a garnishing order can require the bank or employer to pay the money into court.
+
The most common moneys attached are wages and bank accounts. Other sources of money owed to a debtor can also be targets, such as retirement savings funds, estate proceeds (inheritances), or insurance settlements.
  
Money owing from a family court order for child or spousal support can also be garnished under the Family Maintenance Enforcement Program (FMEP) – but garnishment under this program is handled in a completely different way than other kinds of debts (discussed later in this script).
+
For example, say you don’t pay back a loan. The creditor can seek a court order to get your employer to redirect a portion of your wages to the creditor. This process is called '''garnishment'''.
  
==There are two forms of garnishment==
+
===If a creditor wants to take some of a debtor’s wages===
These are:
+
Several steps are involved if a creditor seeks to garnish a debtor’s wages.
*Pre-judgment garnishment
 
*Post-judgment garnishment
 
  
==What is pre-judgment garnishment?==
+
====The creditor needs to get two court orders====
Pre-judgment garnishment allows debts, obligations and liabilities (but not wages) owed to a debtor by others to be attached before the creditor gets a court judgment against the debtor. It helps to preserve these assets of the debtor until the creditor gets judgment. Property or money garnished before a judgment has been obtained is paid into court and held until after the creditor wins their court case and gets judgment against the debtor.
+
A creditor must first get a court judgment against the debtor. The judgment confirms the debtor owes the debt.
  
==What is post-judgment garnishment?==
+
The creditor must then seek a second court order, called a '''garnishing order'''. This is an order requiring a third party who owes money to the debtor (in this case, an employer) to make payments to the creditor.  
Post-judgment garnishment allows debts, obligations and liabilities (including wages) owed to a debtor by others to be intercepted after the creditor obtains a court judgment against the debtor.
 
  
For wages, a portion of the debtor’s wages are protected and cannot be attached. In general, 70% of wages are protected. This is reduced to 50% if the creditor’s claim is for alimony or child support payments.
+
The creditor serves the garnishing order on the employer. The employer must then send a portion of the debtor’s wages to the court. The employer only has to send wages owing within seven days, up to the amount of the debt.  
  
==The law about garnishing orders (especially pre-judgment orders) is very technical==
+
The creditor must then apply to the court to have the money paid out.  
It’s best to get legal advice if you’re faced with this situation. Through the Lawyer Referral Service, you can get some general advice for a small initial fee. Sometimes, you may be able to get the information you need over the phone.
 
  
==Who is involved in garnishment?==
+
====There are laws to protect the debtor====  
Garnishment involves three parties:
+
There’s a limit to how much of a debtor’s wages a creditor can garnish. Usually, that limit is 30% of the debtor’s net income. If the creditor is claiming spousal or child support payments, the limit goes up to 50%.  
*A creditor who seeks payment of a debt
 
*A debtor who owes money to the creditor
 
*A third party (called the “garnishee”) who owes money to the debtor.
 
  
A garnishment action is taken by the creditor against the debtor, as defendant, and the third party, as garnishee. The garnishee is often the debtor’s employer (when wages are garnished) or a bank where the debtor keeps their funds.
+
If garnishing a debtor’s wages causes serious financial hardship, the debtor can apply to court for relief.  
  
==What three important facts should you know about garnishment?==
+
Under the [https://www.canlii.org/en/bc/laws/stat/rsbc-1996-c-78/latest/rsbc-1996-c-78.html#sec27_smooth law in BC], an employer is not allowed to dismiss or demote an employee just because the employer receives a garnishing order. If that has happened to you, you should [[Free and Low-Cost Legal Help (No. 430)|seek legal advice]].
*Garnishment is only made by court order.  
 
*A garnishing order always requires that money is paid to the court. It’s never paid directly to the creditor. The money (or some of it) is only paid from the court to the creditor after the creditor has judgment.
 
*The money owing to the debtor by the garnishee must be owed at the time the garnishing order is delivered to the garnishee. (Some garnishing orders don’t “attach” or collect any money at all because at that particular point in time, no money is owed to the debtor.)
 
  
==What are some examples of garnishment?==
+
===If a creditor wants to draw money from a debtor’s bank account===
Say you work for a warehouse company and your wages are payable every two weeks. You owe money on your Visa card, which you’re not dealing with. The Visa credit card company can intercept your wages and have those wages paid to the court, if it starts a court claim against you and gets a garnishing order.
+
To recover a debt, a creditor may seek to garnish money from the debtor’s bank account.  
  
Or say you are divorced and have been ordered to pay maintenance or financial support to your ex-spouse and/or children. If you’re behind in your support payments, your ex-spouse can apply for a garnishing order to have money taken from your bank account. (Usually, however, garnishment for money owed as child or spousal support is made by the FMEP.)
+
To do so involves several steps. To begin, the creditor brings a legal action for the debt. At the same time as they start this lawsuit, the creditor can seek a garnishing order for the debtor’s bank account. No court hearing is required, and no notice is owed the debtor. For this reason, these types of garnishing orders often take debtors by surprise.
  
Most often, garnishing orders are made against employers who owe wages to employees or against banks and financial institutions that hold deposits for customers.
+
Money that’s garnished from a bank account is paid into court. The creditor can’t access it until they get a judgment against the debtor in their action on the debt.  
  
==How does a creditor get a garnishing order?==
+
Unlike wage garnishments, there’s no limit on how much money can be garnished from a bank account. All the money in the account — up to the amount of the creditor’s judgment — can be taken.
The creditor would first start a lawsuit against you for the debt you owe, and may then ask the court for a garnishing order to take money from your bank or financial institution. If the creditor gets a court judgment against you, the garnishing order can require your employer to pay a portion of your wages into court.
 
  
However, to obtain a garnishing order, the creditor must establish what’s called a “liquidated” claim. This means that the creditor must be able to show exactly what is owed. If, for example, a creditor has a claim against you for damages, such as damages for personal injury or negligence, they cannot obtain a garnishing order, because the exact amount of the damages hasn’t been decided. Once the exact amount has been decided, then a garnishing order can be made.
+
A creditor '''can not''' garnish money from a joint bank account unless they have a court judgment against both account holders.
  
==What happens to the money intercepted by a garnishing order?==
+
===Some types of benefits are protected===
A creditor can obtain a garnishing order even if there is no judgment against you, and even before you’ve been given the court documents starting the lawsuit against you. But the money that is taken from your bank account or employer isn’t automatically paid to the creditor. It’s only paid to the creditor if the creditor carries through with the lawsuit and gets a judgment against you. If you disagree with the claim against you, you can defend the lawsuit. If you’re successful or prove that you don’t owe as much as the creditor claims, then the appropriate amount of money will be paid back out of the court to you.
+
Under the [https://www.canlii.org/en/bc/laws/stat/sbc-2002-c-40/latest/sbc-2002-c-40.html#sec29_smooth law in BC], income assistance received by a debtor cannot be garnished (except where spousal or child support payments are involved; see below).  
  
==What happens if there’s a garnishing order to intercept your wages?==
+
Other types of government benefits are also exempt from garnishment by '''non-government''' creditors, including:
If you’re employed, the creditor can only garnish your wages after obtaining a court judgment against you. While a judgment in a lawsuit can be obtained after a trial in court, judgment can also be obtained by default if you, the debtor, don’t defend the lawsuit.
+
*Canada Pension Plan benefits
 +
*Old Age Security benefits
 +
*Guaranteed Income Supplement payments
  
A garnishing order to intercept wages must be given to your employer within a week of your payday, or it won’t attach any money. Also, when garnishing wages, a new garnishing order has to be issued and given to your employer every pay period. A creditor cannot give the garnishing order once, and hope to intercept your wages every payday. This can make garnishment a slow and expensive process for creditors in collecting a debt.
+
However, most government benefits '''can''' be garnished by government bodies such as the Canada Revenue Agency. Money garnished by the government doesn’t get paid into court. Instead, it goes directly to the government body.
  
But there are exceptions. Some types of garnishing orders can follow your assets and wages for a long time and don’t need to be reissued every payday. If you owe child or spousal support under a court order, then your spouse or partner who is owed the support payment can register with the Family Maintenance Enforcement Program to have your wages continuously garnished. Also, if you owe money to the Canada Revenue Agency for taxes, they can issue a Requirement to Pay to your bank or your employer. A Requirement to Pay can be effective for up to 90 days without having to be re-issued.
+
===If spousal or child support payments are involved===
 +
Special rules apply if the creditor seeking a garnishing order is owed spousal or child support payments. For example, income assistance received by a debtor cannot be garnished — except by the [https://www.fmep.gov.bc.ca/ Family Maintenance Enforcement Program], a government program that enforces court orders for support.  
  
If you’re an independent contractor, your creditor can serve a garnishing order on the person with whom you contract. Even if no money is attached or intercepted, you might find this garnishing order causes you embarrassment.
+
As well, if support payments are involved, a garnishing order for wages does not need to be renewed each pay period. (In other cases, a garnishing order applies only to wages owing within seven days of the order.)
  
==What can you do if garnishing your wages creates a serious hardship for you?==
+
===A debtor can apply to court to set aside a garnishing order===
First, it’s important to note that an employer cannot dismiss or demote an employee simply because the employer is given a garnishing order for the employee’s wages.
+
If a creditor obtains a garnishing order, a debtor can apply to court to set aside (or “release”) the order. The debtor might do this arguing that the order causes them serious financial hardship. Or that the order isn’t necessary to ensure they pay the creditor’s judgment for the debt.  
  
Second, as mentioned, the law generally restricts garnishing orders to attaching only 30% of wages (though up to 50% can be garnished for obligations such as child or spousal support, depending on the debtor’s income and the number of dependents).
+
In applying to release a garnishing order, the material must explain why it would be “just in all the circumstances” to release the order. For example, if you’re claiming a garnishing order causes you serious financial hardship, provide a snapshot of your financial situation. Include a statement of finances and any other information that backs up your position.
  
But you may be able to reduce the amount of wages garnished by applying to the court.
+
{| class="wikitable"
 +
|align="left"|'''Tip'''
 +
People’s Law School’s information on [https://www.peopleslawschool.ca/everyday-legal-problems/money-debt/dealing-debt/creditor-wants-take-money-your-wages-or-bank-account garnishment] provides step-by-step guidance on applying to set aside a garnishing order.  
 +
|}
 +
 +
==Common questions==
  
If the garnishing order creates a serious hardship for you and your family, you can ask a judge or registrar of the court to reduce the percentage of your wages that can be garnished, or to release the garnishment, or to allow you to pay the judgment by installments. Contact the court registry where the order was issued, and make an appointment to have a hearing in front of the registrar. For a Small Claims Court judgment, you’ll probably appear in front of a judge.
+
===I owe money to a creditor. Can they take my entire pay cheque to satisfy the debt?===
 +
No. The [https://www.canlii.org/en/bc/laws/stat/rsbc-1996-c-78/latest/rsbc-1996-c-78.html#sec3_smooth law in BC] says a creditor can garnish up to 30% of a debtor’s net income — that is, after statutory deductions for things like income tax, Canada Pension Plan, and Employment Insurance. This means you’d keep at least 70% of your pay cheque.
  
Keep in mind, however, that the creditor can also ask the court to increase the percentage of wages that can be garnished.
+
Note a garnishing order applies only to wages owing within seven days of the order. A new garnishing order must be issued and given to your employer every pay period.
  
If you apply to the court to pay the judgment by installments, and the court believes this is appropriate, a monthly payment will be set which is manageable for you. There are no court administration costs for this procedure. The creditor will have the right to ask questions about your financial situation, and the judge or registrar may also ask you some questions. If you’re in real financial difficulty, the judge or registrar has the power to order that nothing need be paid for the time being.
+
(Special rules apply if a creditor’s claim is for spousal or child support payments; see above.)
  
==What should you do if you are a garnishee?==
+
===What happens to money paid into court?===
Garnishment involves an order of the court, so if you’re the garnishee (for example, the debtor’s employer), don’t ignore the garnishing order. You must pay the appropriate money to the court. Pay the court whatever you owe the debtor at the time you get the order, up to the amount claimed in the order. Any money that you pay into court doesn’t have to be paid to the person you owe money to (for example, your employee). However if you ignore a garnishing order and pay the debtor instead, you may end up having to pay the money twice – the second time to the creditor.
+
A creditor must apply to court to get access to any money that has been paid into court under a garnishing order.
  
If you as the garnishee believe you don’t owe the debtor anything, then you should contact the court registry and submit what is called a Dispute Note. The Dispute Note explains your reasons why you believe you don’t owe the debtor anything. The Dispute Note doesn’t have to be on a particular form – it can be a letter printed on the garnishee’s letterhead. If the creditor disagrees with you, then a judge will have to decide the matter.
+
===I’ve been served with a garnishing order. What should I do?===
 +
Never ignore a garnishing order served on you. There are serious consequences for not complying with a court order.  
  
Note again that it’s illegal to dismiss or demote an employee who is a debtor because you’ve received a garnishing order, and there may be harsh penalties if you do.
+
You have two options.
 +
#You could pay into court whatever amount you owe the debtor (up to the amount claimed in the garnishing order). Whatever amount you pay into court you don’t have to pay to the debtor.
 +
#Your second option, if you believe you don’t owe the debtor anything, is to file a “dispute note” in court. This note explains why you don’t owe the debtor anything. It doesn’t have to be on a particular form; it can be on your letterhead. If the creditor disagrees with you, then a judge will decide the matter.
  
==What happens to any money paid into court?==
+
==Get help==
If a garnishing order is successful in attaching money, and if money is paid to the court, the creditor cannot have the money paid out to them without a court order or the debtor’s consent.
 
 
 
==What about garnishment by the Family Maintenance Enforcement Program (FMEP)?==
 
The FMEP is a free government program in BC that enforces court orders and agreements for child and spousal support. It can also enforce court orders and agreements from other provinces in some circumstances as well. It has special and wide-ranging powers to garnish bank accounts, tax returns and wages of people obligated to pay support. Many of the rules that apply to normal garnishment don’t apply to garnishment by the FMEP. If you owe money under a support order which is being garnished by the FMEP, you can ask the court to “suspend enforcement” in some cases. But it’s usually better in the long run to negotiate a payment arrangement directly with the FMEP or consult a family lawyer about changing the terms of the court order which caused you to go into debt in the first place.
 
 
 
For more on the FMEP, refer to script [[Enforcing Orders and Agreements for Support (Script 132)|132]] on “Enforcing Orders and Agreements for Support”.
 
 
 
==Where can you get help or find more information?==
 
*If you’re having trouble paying your bills, contact the Credit Counselling Society of BC, a non-profit debt counselling service. They can help set up a debt management program for you. Call 1.888.527.8999 (toll-free) or see their website at [http://www.nomoredebts.org www.nomoredebts.org]. 
 
*Refer to Dial-A-Law script [[When You Can't Pay Your Debts (Script 253)|253]] on “When You Can’t Pay Your Debts”.
 
*See the manual [http://www.legalaid.bc.ca/publications/pub.php?pub=17 Consumer Law and Credit/Debt Law] published by the Legal Services Society, BC and available for free on their website at [http://www.legalaid.bc.ca www.legalaid.bc.ca]. To find it, click “Our Publications” then under “I want to find a publication by subject,” click “Debt”. This manual is for paralegals, legal information counsellors, and lawyers with clients who have consumer/debt problems.
 
 
 
 
 
[updated July 2014]
 
 
 
 
 
----
 
----
 
  
 +
===With managing your finances===
 +
The '''Credit Counselling Society of BC''' is a non-profit society that helps people better manage their money and debt.
 +
:Toll-free: 1-888-527-8999
 +
:Web: [http://www.nomoredebts.org/ nomoredebts.org]
  
 +
{{Dial-A-Law_Navbox|type=consumer}}
 
{{Dial-A-Law Copyright}}
 
{{Dial-A-Law Copyright}}

Latest revision as of 22:03, 29 March 2019

This information applies to British Columbia, Canada. Last reviewed for legal accuracy by Rachel Lammers, Morelli Chertkow LLP in July 2018.

When a debtor doesn’t pay a debt, a creditor may try to access money owed to the debtor by someone else. The creditor can do this through a process called garnishment.

Understand your legal rights

Garnishment is a way to collect a debt

Under the law in BC, if a debtor doesn’t pay a debt, a creditor can tap into money the debtor is owed by someone else (that is, a third party).

The creditor must go to court to do this. They can ask the court to “attach” (or “garnish”) money owed to the debtor and redirect it to the creditor.

The most common moneys attached are wages and bank accounts. Other sources of money owed to a debtor can also be targets, such as retirement savings funds, estate proceeds (inheritances), or insurance settlements.

For example, say you don’t pay back a loan. The creditor can seek a court order to get your employer to redirect a portion of your wages to the creditor. This process is called garnishment.

If a creditor wants to take some of a debtor’s wages

Several steps are involved if a creditor seeks to garnish a debtor’s wages.

The creditor needs to get two court orders

A creditor must first get a court judgment against the debtor. The judgment confirms the debtor owes the debt.

The creditor must then seek a second court order, called a garnishing order. This is an order requiring a third party who owes money to the debtor (in this case, an employer) to make payments to the creditor.

The creditor serves the garnishing order on the employer. The employer must then send a portion of the debtor’s wages to the court. The employer only has to send wages owing within seven days, up to the amount of the debt.

The creditor must then apply to the court to have the money paid out.

There are laws to protect the debtor

There’s a limit to how much of a debtor’s wages a creditor can garnish. Usually, that limit is 30% of the debtor’s net income. If the creditor is claiming spousal or child support payments, the limit goes up to 50%.

If garnishing a debtor’s wages causes serious financial hardship, the debtor can apply to court for relief.

Under the law in BC, an employer is not allowed to dismiss or demote an employee just because the employer receives a garnishing order. If that has happened to you, you should seek legal advice.

If a creditor wants to draw money from a debtor’s bank account

To recover a debt, a creditor may seek to garnish money from the debtor’s bank account.

To do so involves several steps. To begin, the creditor brings a legal action for the debt. At the same time as they start this lawsuit, the creditor can seek a garnishing order for the debtor’s bank account. No court hearing is required, and no notice is owed the debtor. For this reason, these types of garnishing orders often take debtors by surprise.

Money that’s garnished from a bank account is paid into court. The creditor can’t access it until they get a judgment against the debtor in their action on the debt.

Unlike wage garnishments, there’s no limit on how much money can be garnished from a bank account. All the money in the account — up to the amount of the creditor’s judgment — can be taken.

A creditor can not garnish money from a joint bank account unless they have a court judgment against both account holders.

Some types of benefits are protected

Under the law in BC, income assistance received by a debtor cannot be garnished (except where spousal or child support payments are involved; see below).

Other types of government benefits are also exempt from garnishment by non-government creditors, including:

  • Canada Pension Plan benefits
  • Old Age Security benefits
  • Guaranteed Income Supplement payments

However, most government benefits can be garnished by government bodies such as the Canada Revenue Agency. Money garnished by the government doesn’t get paid into court. Instead, it goes directly to the government body.

If spousal or child support payments are involved

Special rules apply if the creditor seeking a garnishing order is owed spousal or child support payments. For example, income assistance received by a debtor cannot be garnished — except by the Family Maintenance Enforcement Program, a government program that enforces court orders for support.

As well, if support payments are involved, a garnishing order for wages does not need to be renewed each pay period. (In other cases, a garnishing order applies only to wages owing within seven days of the order.)

A debtor can apply to court to set aside a garnishing order

If a creditor obtains a garnishing order, a debtor can apply to court to set aside (or “release”) the order. The debtor might do this arguing that the order causes them serious financial hardship. Or that the order isn’t necessary to ensure they pay the creditor’s judgment for the debt.

In applying to release a garnishing order, the material must explain why it would be “just in all the circumstances” to release the order. For example, if you’re claiming a garnishing order causes you serious financial hardship, provide a snapshot of your financial situation. Include a statement of finances and any other information that backs up your position.

Tip

People’s Law School’s information on garnishment provides step-by-step guidance on applying to set aside a garnishing order.

Common questions

I owe money to a creditor. Can they take my entire pay cheque to satisfy the debt?

No. The law in BC says a creditor can garnish up to 30% of a debtor’s net income — that is, after statutory deductions for things like income tax, Canada Pension Plan, and Employment Insurance. This means you’d keep at least 70% of your pay cheque.

Note a garnishing order applies only to wages owing within seven days of the order. A new garnishing order must be issued and given to your employer every pay period.

(Special rules apply if a creditor’s claim is for spousal or child support payments; see above.)

What happens to money paid into court?

A creditor must apply to court to get access to any money that has been paid into court under a garnishing order.

I’ve been served with a garnishing order. What should I do?

Never ignore a garnishing order served on you. There are serious consequences for not complying with a court order.

You have two options.

  1. You could pay into court whatever amount you owe the debtor (up to the amount claimed in the garnishing order). Whatever amount you pay into court you don’t have to pay to the debtor.
  2. Your second option, if you believe you don’t owe the debtor anything, is to file a “dispute note” in court. This note explains why you don’t owe the debtor anything. It doesn’t have to be on a particular form; it can be on your letterhead. If the creditor disagrees with you, then a judge will decide the matter.

Get help

With managing your finances

The Credit Counselling Society of BC is a non-profit society that helps people better manage their money and debt.

Toll-free: 1-888-527-8999
Web: nomoredebts.org
Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International Licence Dial-A-Law © People's Law School is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution - NonCommercial - ShareAlike 4.0 International Licence.


Personal tools
Namespaces

Variants
Actions
Site
Tools
Contributors
Print/export