Difference between revisions of "Divorce Act Basics"

Jump to navigation Jump to search

Divorce Act Basics (view source)

Revision as of 22:39, 31 March 2013

25,383 bytes added ,  22:39, 31 March 2013
no edit summary
(Created page with "{{JP Boyd on Family Law TOC}} {{JP Boyd on Family Law Navbox|type=started}}")
 
Line 1: Line 1:
{{JP Boyd on Family Law TOC}}
{{JP Boyd on Family Law TOC}}
The federal ''Divorce Act'' is the Canadian legislation on marriage breakdown. It only applies to spouses who are married to each or who used to be married to each other. It talks about how married spouses get divorced and when divorce orders obtained in another country are recognized here. It also deals with the care of children after separation, child support and spousal support.
This page provides an overview of the ''Divorce Act.'' It is primarily written for justice system workers and legal advocates, but can be used by anybody.
==Introduction==
===Who does the Divorce Act'' apply to?===
The ''Divorce Act'' is the main law on marriage breakdown in Canada. It applies to people who are or were married to each other, regardless of where the spouses were married. If other kinds of couples want orders about the care of children, child support or spousal support and can't make an agreement, they must apply under provincial legislation. In British Columbia, this is the ''Family Law Act''.
Other people can use the ''Divorce Act'' to ask for orders about the care of children, but:
#they can only apply if there is already a court proceeding between married spouses; and,
#they must first get the court's permission to make an application.
===What does the ''Divorce Act'' cover?===
The ''Divorce Act'' deals with:
#divorce;
#foreign divorce orders;
#custody of children;
#access to children;
#paying child support and how child support is calculated;
#paying spousal support; and,
#changing orders about custody, access, child support and spousal support.
====What is "corollary relief"?====
The ''Divorce Act'' describes issues about the care of children and support as "corollary relief". ''Corollary'' means "related to"; a court hearing a court proceeding can make orders about the care of children and support because they are related to the court's ability to make a divorce order.
====What about annulment?====
When a marriage is ''annulled'', it is cancelled as if the parties had never been married at all. A marriage can be annulled if there is a problem with the legal requirements of the marriage ceremony or the legal capacity of the parties to marry.
The ''Divorce Act'' doesn't talk about when marriages can be "annulled". Annulment is governed by the common law and is nowhere near as easy to get as a divorce.
===When can a court proceeding under the ''Divorce Act'' start?===
A court proceeding for a divorce order can only start when either spouse has lived in the province where the proceeding is started for at least one year.  As long as this requirement is met, a court proceeding can be started as soon as the spouses have separated.
===Which court can hear a proceeding under the ''Divorce Act''?===
Both the Provincial Court and the Supreme Court can hear court proceedings under the provincial ''Family Law Act''. Only the Supreme Court has the jurisdiction to hear proceedings under the ''Divorce Act''.
===What happens if each spouse starts a court proceeding?===
If each spouse starts a divorce proceeding, the court in which a proceeding was started first can continue to deal with that proceeding and the proceeding that was started last is considered to be dropped. This can be very important where spouses live in different provinces.
If the spouses somehow manage to start separate divorce proceedings on the same day, the proceedings are to be transferred to the Federal Court. The Federal Court is a trial court like the Supreme Court of British Columbia but is common to all of Canada.
===What about claims under the ''Family Law Act''?===
Both the ''Divorce Act'' and the ''Family Law Act'' talk about the care of child, child support and spousal support. As a long a person is married, he or she can start a court proceeding about these issues under either law or under both laws at the same time.
====Child Support====
The rules about child support are almost the same between the two laws, except that it can be easier to get child support from a stepparent under the ''Family Law Act''.
====Spousal Support====
The rules about spousal support are very similar between the two laws, except that under the ''Family Law Act'' spousal support is also available to couples that aren't married to each other.
Under the ''Family Law Act'', however, someone who is entitled to ask for spousal support must begin a court proceeding for spousal support within two years of divorce, if the couple were married, or within two years of separation, if the couple wasn't married, or they will be out of time. There's no limit to when claims can be brought under the ''Divorce Act''.
====Children====
The two laws are the most different in terms of how they talk about children. The ''Divorce Act'' talks about spouses who have custody and access. The ''Family Law Act'' talks about guardians who have parental responsibilities and parenting time, and people who aren't guardians who have contact.
I prefer how the ''Family Law Act'' deals with children. It's more focused on the rights and interests of children and less focused on the rights of parents.
Because the two systems are so different, even though a married spouse can make a claim under both laws, it's best just to pick one. It will be less confusing for the court and less confusing for the parties involved.
==Divorce==
===Why will the court make a divorce order?===
Under s. 8(1) of the ''Divorce Act'', the court can make a divorce order only if the spouses' marriage has broken down. Under s. 8(2), there are three reasons why a marriage may have broken down:
#because the spouses have lived separate and apart for at least one year;
#because one spouse has committed adultery, and the adultery hasn't been forgiven by the other spouse; or,
#because one spouse has treated the other with such cruelty that the spouses cannot continue to live together.
====Separation====
To get a divorce based on separation, the spouses must have lived separate and apart for one year.
The period of living separate and apart can pass while living under the same roof, however the partnership quality of the relationship between the spouses must have ended. In general, this means that the spouses have stopped sleeping together, eating meals together, doing chores for each other and going out together as a couple.
Under s. 8(3), the spouses can attempt to reconcile and resume married life for up to 90 days during the one-year period. However, if the couple lives together for a total period of more than 90 days, the clock resets and a new one-year period doesn't start running until the last separation.
====Adultery====
To get a divorce based on adultery, the spouse asking for the divorce has to be able to prove that his or her spouse had sex with someone else, without his or her permission. The evidence the court will require isn't circumstantial evidence, like a hotel receipt, but direct evidence, like a photograph or the spouse's admission.
A spouse can't ask for a divorce because of his or her own adultery.
====Cruelty====
To get a divorce based on cruelty, the spouse asking for the divorce has to be able to prove that he or she was treated with such mental or physical cruelty that it was impossible to continue living together. The evidence of cruelty that the court will require must some from someone else, like a doctor or a psychologist. The spouse's own evidence won't do.
A spouse can't ask for a divorce because of his or her own cruelty.
====The Effect of Forgiveness====
The court will not grant a divorce based on adultery or cruelty if the adultery or cruelty has been forgiven. If it has been forgiven, the marital relationship hasn't broken down and the court can't make the divorce order.
===When can the court make the divorce order?===
If the claim for the divorce is based on separation, the spouse cannot apply for the divorce order until one year has passed from the date of separation. The one-year period doesn't run from the date the court proceeding is started, it runs from the date of separation.
The nice thing about claims based on adultery or cruelty is that the application for divorce can be made right away, without having to wait for one year. However, the adultery or cruelty must be proven and if more than year has passed by the time the court is asked to make the divorce order the court may very well refuse to make the divorce order except because of the spouses' separation.
===What about child support?===
The court may not make a divorce order unless it is satisfied that adequate arrangements have been made for child support. Section 11(1)(b) of the ''Divorce Act'' says that the court has the duty to:
<blockquote><tt>to satisfy itself that reasonable arrangements have been made for the support of any children of the marriage, having regard to the applicable guidelines, and, if such arrangements have not been made, to stay the granting of the divorce until such arrangements are made</tt></blockquote>
In other words, the court will usually refuse to make a divorce order unless child support is being paid in the amount that would normally be required by the Child Support Guidelines.
===When is a divorce order effective?===
Under s. 12(1), a divorce order takes effect on the thirty-first day after the divorce order is made. That's because under s. 21(3) the deadline to make an appeal of a ''Divorce Act'' order is the thirtieth day after the order is made.
===What's the legal effect of a divorce order?===
A divorce is the legal end of a marriage, and has effect throughout Canada. Once that happens, the divorced spouse can remarry and his or her ex is no longer assumed to be entitled to share in the spouse's estate.
===What if spouses wait to get a divorced order?===
Getting a divorce is often a low priority for spouses and some spouses wait for many years before starting a court proceeding for divorce. This isn't unreasonable, and usually happens for one of three reasons:
#the cost of getting a divorce can be too high;
#other issues, like the care of children or the division of property and debt, take priority; or,
#a spouse's religion discourages divorce.
====No Divorce without a Divorce Order====
No matter how long spouses wait, they will always be married to each other until one of them dies or they get divorced. There's no automatic divorce.
====New Relationships====
Spouses often move on with their lives after separation, meet new people and get into new romantic relationships without being divorced. There's nothing wrong with this, and it won't stop the spouse from getting a divorce when the time is finally ripe.
However, if it takes too long and a separated spouse moves in to live with someone new, it's entirely possible that the spouse can find him- or herself in a new spousal relationship without being divorced. Remember that under the ''Family Law Act'' people can become spouses without getting married.
===Foreign Divorce Orders===
Under s. 22 of the ''Divorce Act'', a divorce order made outside of Canada will be recognized here, and be effective to determine a person's marital status here, as long as at least one of the spouses lived in the country that made the divorce order for at least one year before the divorce proceeding was started.
==The Law About Children==
===Who is a child?===
The ''Divorce Act'' talks about "children of the marriage." A child is a child of two spouses who is under the age of 19, the age of majority in British Columbia, or 19 and older but "unable to withdraw" from care of the spouses.
Although a court can make orders about the care of children who are under the age of 19, in practice the court usually won't make orders about children who are 15 and older. Children who are that old are usually old enough to make decisions for themselves about where they'd like to live.
===How are decisions about children made?===
Section 16(8) of the ''Divorce Act'' says that the court should take "only the best interests of the child of the marriage as determined by reference to the condition, means, needs and other circumstances of the child" into account when making decisions about children.
The ''Divorce Act'' doesn't go into any further detail than this except to say, at s. 16(10), that:
<blockquote><tt>the court shall give effect to the principle that a child of the marriage should have as much contact with each spouse as is consistent with the best interests of the child and, for that purpose, shall take into consideration the willingness of the person for whom custody is sought to facilitate such contact.</tt></blockquote>
 
===Orders for Custody and Access===
Under s. 16(1) of the ''Divorce Act'', a spouse or "any other person" can apply to court for an order that he or she has custody of or access to a child. However, a person who is not a spouse cannot make the application without first getting the court's permission.
Access usually refers to the parenting schedule of someone who isn't a spouse or the parenting schedule of the spouse who sees the child for the least amount of time.
====Sole Custody and Joint Custody====
Under s. 16(4), the court can order that one or more persons have custody of or access to a child.
*When only one person has custody, that person has ''sole custody'' of the child.
*When more than one person has custody, they have ''joint custody'' of the child.
====What rights does custody give?====
A spouse with sole custody has the child's primary residence and is responsible for the child on a day-to-day basis
An order for joint custody gives each spouse custody of the children. In such cases the spouses need to and are expected to work together and cooperate in the raising of their children. The children may still spend more time, sometimes a lot more time, at one spouse's home than the other, but both spouses have the right to participate in making decisions about the children's care, welfare and upbringing.
====What rights does access give?====
Access is a schedule of a spouse's time with a child.
More than this, however, under s. 16(5) a spouse who has access also has "the right to make inquiries, and to be given information, as to the health, education and welfare of the child." This doesn't apply to people who are not spouses who have access to the child.
===How are orders for custody and access enforced?===
Orders for custody and access have effect throughout Canada, and are enforced under the laws of each province. In British Columbia, ''Divorce Act'' orders can be enforced by a spouse under the rules of court and the provincial ''Court Order Enforcement Act'', and by a spouse and the Family Maintenance Enforcement Program under the provincial ''Family Maintenance Enforcement Act''.
===How are orders for custody and access changed?===
Under s. 17(1), a spouse or another person can apply to change an order for custody or access, but someone who isn't a spouse has to first get permission from the court.
The legal test that must be met before the court changes an order for custody or access is at s. 17(5):
<blockquote><tt>Before the court makes a variation order in respect of a custody order, the court shall satisfy itself that there has been a change in the condition, means, needs or other circumstances of the child of the marriage occurring since the making of the custody order or the last variation order made in respect of that order, as the case may be, and, in making the variation order, the court shall take into consideration only the best interests of the child as determined by reference to that change.</tt></blockquote>
In other words, someone who wants to change an order must first show that that there has been a change in circumstances. Then, when the court is deciding on a new order it must consider the best interests of the child in light of that change.
==The Law About Child Support==
===Who is a child?===
The ''Divorce Act'' talks about "children of the marriage." A child is a child of two spouses who is under the age of 19, the age of majority in British Columbia, or 19 and older but "unable to withdraw" from care of the spouses. Normally, adult children who are unable to withdraw are children who are ill or disabled or who are going to school full-time and are unable to support themselves.
===Who is a spouse?===
In this context, "spouse" includes a spouse who is parent of a child and a spouse who "stands in the place of a parent" for a child. In other words, spouse includes spouses who are ''stepparents''.
===Who is required to pay child support?===
Section 15.1(1) of the ''Divorce Act'' says that a court may "make an order requiring a spouse to pay for the support of any or all children of the marriage". The act doesn't say that it's ''parents'' who have to pay, it's ''spouses'' who have to pay and spouse includes stepparents.
===Who can ask for child support?===
Under s. 15.1(1) only spouses can ask for child support orders. If someone other than a spouse has custody of a child and child support, the person will need to apply for child support under the provincial ''Family Law Act''.
===How is the amount of child support calculated?===
Child support is determined by the Child Support Guidelines. Most of the time, child support is simple to figure out by looking up the amount payable in the Guidelines tables based on the payor’s income and the number of children support is being paid for. Child support can get more complicated when:
#a child is 19 or older;
#the payor has an income of more than $150,000 per year;
#one more children live mostly with each guardian, called ''split custody'';
#the guardians share the children’s time equally or almost equally, called ''shared custody''; or,
#the payment of the tables amount would cause "undue hardship" to either the recipient or the payor.
===How is child support paid?===
Most of the time, child support is paid every month, usually on the first day of the month. It is possible for child support to be paid in a single lump sum, but this is very rare. Payors can be required to pay by giving the recipient a series of post-dated cheques.
===How are orders for child support changed?===
Under s. 17(4) of the ''Divorce Act'', the court can change an order for child support if there has been a change in circumstances that would result in a different amount of support being paid, such as an increase or a decrease in the payor's income, a change in how the children's time is divided between the spouses.
====When Both Spouses Live in British Columbia====
To change a British Columbia ''Divorce Act'' child support order when both spouses live here, the applicant must file a Notice of Application in the original court proceeding. The Supreme Court Family Rules have special provisions for applications to change final orders.
====When A Spouse Lives outside of British Columbia====
To change a British Columbia ''Divorce Act'' child support order when the Respondent lives in another province, the Applicant first applies here, in British Columbia, for a ''provisional order'' under s. 18.
If the court makes a provisional order, it will send the order to the province where the Respondent lives, and the court there will have a hearing to ''confirm'' the provisional order under s. 19. The court at the confirmation hearing may:
#confirm the provisional order;
#confirm the provisional order with some changes;
#refuse to confirm the provisional order; or,
#send the application back to British Columbia for more information.
A provisional order has no effect until it is confirmed.
==The Law About Spousal Support==
===Who is entitled to ask for spousal support?===
Only spouses can ask for spousal support. Under s. 15 of the ''Divorce Act'', "spouse" includes ''former spouses'', spouses who have been divorced. There is no time limit on when a spouse or former spousal can ask for child support.
A spouse’s entitlement to spousal support is determined based on factors set out at s. 15.2(4):
<blockquote><tt>In making an order [for spousal support], the court shall take into consideration the condition, means, needs and other circumstances of each spouse, including</tt></blockquote>
<blockquote><blockquote><tt>(a) the length of time the spouses cohabited; </tt></blockquote></blockquote>
<blockquote><blockquote><tt>(b) the functions performed by each spouse during cohabitation; and</tt></blockquote></blockquote>
<blockquote><blockquote><tt>(c) any order, agreement or arrangement relating to support of either spouse.</tt></blockquote></blockquote>
Remember that no one is automatically entitled to get spousal support the way a child is automatically entitled to benefit from child support. Anyone who is a spouse can ''ask'' for spousal support, but being able to ask doesn’t mean they’ll get it. They must also show that they are entitled to spousal support.
===How are the amount and duration of spousal support calculated?===
When a spouse is entitled to receive spousal support, the amount to be paid and the length of time support should be paid for, called ''duration'', is determined based on factors set out at s. 15.2(6):
<blockquote><tt>An order [for spousal support] should</tt></blockquote><
<blockquote><blockquote><tt>(a) recognize any economic advantages or disadvantages to the spouses arising from the marriage or its breakdown; </tt></blockquote></blockquote>
<blockquote><blockquote><tt>(b) apportion between the spouses any financial consequences arising from the care of any child of the marriage over and above any obligation for the support of any child of the marriage; </tt></blockquote></blockquote>
<blockquote><blockquote><tt>(c) relieve any economic hardship of the spouses arising from the breakdown of the marriage; and</tt></blockquote></blockquote>
<blockquote><blockquote><tt>(d) in so far as practicable, promote the economic self-sufficiency of each spouse within a reasonable period of time. </tt></blockquote></blockquote>
The amount of spousal support to be paid and the duration that it should be paid for is often determined using the Spousal Support Advisory Guidelines. The Advisory Guidelines is not a law like the Child Support Guidelines and is not mandatory. The ''Divorce Act'' does not mention the Advisory Guidelines.
===Is a spouse’s conduct taken into account?===
Under the ''Divorce Act'', the court is not allowed to consider a spouse’s behaviour when making an order about spousal support.
===How is spousal support paid?===
Most of the time, spousal support is paid every month, usually on the first day of the month. It is possible for spousal support to be paid in a single lump sum. Payors can be required to pay by giving the recipient a series of post-dated cheques.
===Are there tax consequences?===
There are tax consequences when spousal support is paid on a regular basis. Spousal support is tax neutral when it is paid as a single lump sum.
The recipient of regular payments of spousal support must declare the support received in his or her income tax return and pay tax on it, just as if the support payments were employment income. The payor can deduct the spousal support paid from his or her taxable income, like how RRSP contributions can be deducted from taxable income. This usually means that the recipient has to pay tax at the end of the year while the payor gets a tax refund.
Remember that taxes should be taken into account when figuring out spousal support. At a minimum, recipients should be reminded to put some money aside to pay their taxes.
===How are orders for spousal support changed?===
Under s. 17(4.1) of the ''Divorce Act'', the court can change an order for spousal support if there has been a:
<blockquote><tt>change in the condition, means, needs or other circumstances of either former spouse has occurred since the making of the spousal support order or the last variation order made in respect of that order</tt></blockquote>
When the court varies an order for spousal support, it must take the change of circumstances into account and consider, under s. 17(7), the same factors about amount and duration as it considered in making the original order.
====When Both Spouses Live in British Columbia====
To change a British Columbia ''Divorce Act'' spousal support order when both spouses live here, the applicant must file a Notice of Application in the original court proceeding. The Supreme Court Family Rules have special provisions for applications to change final orders.
====When A Spouse Lives outside of British Columbia====
To change a British Columbia ''Divorce Act'' spousal support order when the Respondent lives in another province, the Applicant first applies here, in British Columbia, for a ''provisional order'' under s. 18.
If the court makes a provisional order, it will send the order to the province where the Respondent lives, and the court there will have a hearing to ''confirm'' the provisional order under s. 19. The court at the confirmation hearing may:
#confirm the provisional order;
#confirm the provisional order with some changes;
#refuse to confirm the provisional order; or,
#send the application back to British Columbia for more information.
A provisional order has no effect until it is confirmed.


{{JP Boyd on Family Law Navbox|type=started}}
{{JP Boyd on Family Law Navbox|type=started}}
Retrieved from "https://stagewiki.clicklaw.bc.ca/index.php?title=Special:MobileDiff/6577"

Navigation menu